2500 Monterey St, Sarasota, FL 34231

About this home

Modern Waterfront Living on Phillippi Creek with 170 Ft Water Frontage: this stunning residence was completely rebuilt down to the studs in 2023, this move-in ready modern contemporary waterfront residence sits on a rare 0.36-acre lot with 170 feet of water frontage and complete privacy across the creek—offering open water views, and breathtaking westerly Sarasota sunsets. Home has never had water intrusion from any storms due to its elevation. Located on a quiet cul-de-sac just 5 miles to Downtown Sarasota and 3 miles to Siesta Key, the property combines convenience with a peaceful waterfront setting. The home has never flooded and was thoughtfully renovated with long-term durability and quality construction in mind. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the 5ft +/- water depth at the dock, with additional dredging happening along the creek and an expansive boat dock with new flow-through composite decking, boat lift, and separate double jet ski lift. Enjoy direct access to Sarasota Bay and the Gulf of America just minutes from your backyard. Inside, soaring ceilings and expansive PGT impact windows and sliders fill the home with natural light while framing serene water views. The open-concept living space is centered around a chef’s kitchen featuring a dramatic oversized quartz waterfall island, sleek quartz countertops & backsplash, custom cabinetry, and premium appliances— designed for both daily living and entertaining. The primary bedroom suite offers generous proportions and a fully customized walk-in closet with boutique-level organization the size of its own bedroom. The comprehensive 2023 renovation included full re-plumbing, all new electrical wiring, and fully remodeled bathrooms. Additional upgrades since then include a handcrafted iron front entry door, modern 4 panel garage door with side mounted motor, epoxy flooring and metal standing seam roof. Outdoor living rivals a private resort with a heated saltwater pool and a 2025 custom outdoor kitchen equipped with gas grill, flat-top hibachi grill, built-in TV, refrigerators, and wine cooler. Exterior enhancements include motorized screen, artificial turf for low maintenance, oversized 5 car paver driveway, landscape lighting, leaf guard gutters, and a 12x34 ft shed on an extended concrete pad down to the water's edge. A rare combination of modern construction, deep water access, wide water frontage, and close proximity to Sarasota’s top destinations—this is move in ready waterfront living without settling. It's not just renovated; it's a rare package. All furnishings are negotiable.

Key facts

Type

Single Family Residence

Size

2,434 sqft

Bedrooms

3

Bathrooms

3

Avg. price per sqft

$822

Days on market

45

Year built

1986

Lot size

0.36 acres

Parking

2-car garage

Annual taxes

$10,090

Flood zone

AE

Heating

Central, Electric

Cooling

Central Air

Waterfront

Yes

Furnished

Negotiable

Subdivision

GLENCOE

Financing

Cash, Conventional

Stories

2

Levels

Multi/Split

County

Sarasota

MLS number

A4699306

Status

Active

Property address

2500 Monterey St, Sarasota, FL 34231

Features and extras

• Dishwasher
• Disposal
• Dryer
• Microwave
• Range Hood
• Refrigerator
• Washer
• Eating Space In Kitchen
• PrimaryBedroom Upstairs
• Solid Surface Counters
• Thermostat
• Window Treatments
• Lighting
• Rain Gutters
• Sliding Doors
• Storage
• Gunite
• Heated
• In Ground
• Inside
• Laundry Room
• Porcelain Tile
• Vinyl

Property details

Schools

District

Sarasota County School District

Elementary

PHILLIPPI SHORES ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

Middle

BROOKSIDE MIDDLE SCHOOL

High

RIVERVIEW HIGH SCHOOL

School grades from FLDOE public records. District polygons and school points from NCES EDGE. Assignment is not a legal attendance guarantee. Composite scores, when present, are derived from public records and are not official FLDOE grades.

Where is this home?

Common questions