Back to news

Selling

Pricing Your Tampa Bay Home When Buyers Have More Choices

Blue stucco single-story home with palm trees and a For Sale sign in the front yard in a Tampa Bay neighborhood, with the headline Pricing Your Tampa Bay Home When Buyers Have More Choices.

If you're selling in Pinellas or Hillsborough, the number on the sign has to hold up against the homes buyers can tour this week. They have more listings to walk through, and they can take their time. Your house can still sell. The asking price just has to make sense next to those choices.

When I sit down with a Tampa Bay seller, I usually walk through three questions. What else can buyers tour this week? What might you give in an offer, and what would you net? And what do the showings and the feedback tell you?

What buyers compare your house against this week

A lot of owners start with a nearby sale and assume their house should come in around the same number. Closed sales matter. I use them. They just aren't the whole picture, because that sale is already behind us.

The buyer standing in your living room isn't measuring your house against a closing from last spring. They're lining it up against the listings they can walk through this week, including the one that just came on the market down the street. When more similar homes are available, that comparison gets sharper. A price that would have felt reasonable last year can look high next to a well-kept house that's already on the market.

When we look at a sale together in St. Pete, Clearwater, Brandon, or South Tampa, we start with how many similar homes are for sale nearby, what similar homes actually sold for (closed sales, not list prices), and what buyers want right now, which often includes condition, roof age, flood history, and insurance costs.

I don't always try to come in under every other listing. I want the price to show a buyer why this is the house to pick.

Jake Krimmel, a senior economist at Realtor.com, put it this way in an August 24, 2026 article: "Pricing to today's demand is helping homes move and keeping more transactions alive in a high-rate environment."

That's a national observation, not a promise about your street. It's still a useful way to think about the asking price. Two houses a mile apart can need different numbers, especially when roof age, flood history, or insurance costs are not the same.

What you give versus what you net

A solid asking price helps when offers start to arrive. But the price isn't the whole deal.

Buyers may still ask you to cover some closing costs, pay for repairs, or fund a rate buydown, even when the list price is in the right range. That request can show up for reasons that have nothing to do with a pricing mistake.

Redfin, in a September 18, 2026 report, looked at sales in the three months ending August 31, 2026. In that period, sellers gave a concession in 44.7% of U.S. home sales. Redfin's count includes credits for repairs, closing costs, or a rate buydown. It doesn't treat a lower list price as a concession. In the same period, 15.8% of sales included a reduced price plus a concession.

Bar chart titled Nearly Half of U.S. Home Sales Included a Seller Concession, covering U.S. home sales in the three months ending August 31, 2026: 44.7% were sales with seller concessions, and 15.8% were sales with a price cut and a concession, a group that is part of the 44.7%. Source: Redfin, September 18, 2026. Based on Redfin buyers' agent data.

Those figures come from Redfin's buyer-agent data. They aren't a rule for your house, and they aren't a reason to say yes to every request. Sometimes a credit at closing is worth talking through. Sometimes it makes more sense to say no. Before you decide, I want you to weigh the full offer and what you'd net after the credits.

If a rate buydown comes up, I wrote about price cuts and rate buydowns for Tampa Bay sellers. Concession limits also vary by loan type, and I walked through those limits in Seller Concession Limits by Loan Type. Those loan-type caps may limit how much the seller can contribute, so they're worth checking before you agree to a number.

What showings and feedback tell you

Even a well-set price doesn't always bring a quick sale. If showings or offers are quieter than you hoped, that isn't a failed listing. It's a reason to read the feedback, not a reason to cut the price on day one.

Once the house is listed, I look at the activity in a few ways.

Is the listing getting views online, but almost no one is asking to come inside? The photos, the first look, or how the house is staged may be getting in the way.

Are buyers coming through and then going quiet? The issue may be wear and tear, the asking number, or whether the last home they visited made yours look less appealing.

Are offers coming in with terms you can't live with? That can be a negotiation issue, not a cue to drop the list price.

A lower list price can help when it answers the real objection. I wrote about why Tampa Bay sellers are cutting prices and what that can mean. If you're also worried an offer will fall apart later, I wrote about how sellers prepare when a buyer might back out.

If you're selling in Tampa Bay

There's no single asking price you can set once and ignore. You pick a starting number that holds up against the homes buyers can see now, you look at what you'd net after any credits, and you change course if the feedback says you should.

If you want to talk through a sale, book a consultation. We'll look at your house and at what's for sale nearby. As a Realtor with Realty of America, I can help with the sale. As a Mortgage Loan Originator with PMF, Inc., I can help if you're also financing your next home. They are separate companies, and you don't have to use both.

Sources, all checked November 20, 2026: Julie Gerstein, Realtor.com, August 24, 2026 (Jake Krimmel quote). Dana Anderson, Redfin, September 18, 2026 (sellers gave a concession in 44.7% of U.S. sales, and 15.8% of sales included a reduced price plus a concession, for the three months ending August 31, 2026).

This article is for education only. It is not a promise about the sale of any home, and it is not a promise about prices, concessions, or a loan.


Jonathan Loescher, Tampa Bay Realtor and Mortgage Loan Originator (SL3546365, NMLS 2621894)

Jonathan Loescher, Realtor, Florida real estate license SL3546365, Realty of America. Jonathan Loescher, Mortgage Loan Originator, NMLS 2621894. Mortgage loans are originated through PMF, Inc., NMLS 1980, a Florida licensed Mortgage Broker. Real estate and mortgage services are provided by separate companies, and you don't have to use both. Verify licensing at www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org. Equal Housing Opportunity. Any loan approval is conditional until all underwriting conditions are met.

Common questions

How do I start buying a home in Tampa Bay?
Start with a consult and a pre-approval. Pick two or three areas, sign a buyer agreement, and tour. Get insurance quotes early. I'm a Realtor and, separately, a licensed Mortgage Loan Originator with PMF, Inc. Those are two separate companies, and you don't have to use both. Any loan approval is conditional until all underwriting conditions are met.
What are the first-time home buyer steps in Tampa Bay?
Check your budget and credit. Get pre-approved and ask about down payment assistance. Sign a buyer agreement, tour homes, and make an offer. Inspect and get insurance quotes. Clear your loan conditions and close. File homestead after you move in. Any loan approval is conditional until all underwriting conditions are met.
How much are closing costs in Florida for a buyer?
It depends on your price, loan, and contract. Buyers usually pay loan fees, appraisal, the lender's title policy, settlement and recording fees, and Florida's doc stamp and intangible taxes on the new mortgage. Prepaids add homeowners insurance, escrow for taxes, and interest. Your Loan Estimate shows them. Cash buyers skip the mortgage taxes and loan fees.
What is earnest money in Florida?
Earnest money is your good faith deposit after an accepted offer. It's held in escrow and credited at closing. The contract sets when it's due and when you can cancel and get it back, such as during the inspection period or under a financing contingency. Miss a deadline, and it can be at risk. Confirm wiring instructions by phone.
How does the Florida buyer-broker agreement work after NAR?
Compensation is negotiated in writing. It is not automatic that the seller pays. I will walk the buyer-broker agreement with you before you tour. Do not assume buyers pay nothing.

More Tampa Bay home and loan answers on Ask Jonathan.

Enjoying this? Make us a preferred source on Google.

Clearwater market snapshot

Live MLS figures for Clearwater.

Homes for sale
1,397
Median list price
$324,900
Median days on market
77

Listings courtesy of Beaches MLS and Stellar MLS

See homes in Clearwater

More in this series

Apply for a Mortgage

You're leaving jonathanloescher.com for the secure loan application of PMF, Inc., NMLS# 1980. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Jonathan Loescher, Mortgage Loan Originator, NMLS# 2621894 | PMF, Inc. NMLS# 1980

Open the application if the form does not appear.